Buprenorphine’s Black Eye
Buprenorphine/naloxone for opioid dependence, a.k.a. Suboxone treatment, became available in 2003, just as the epidemic of pain pill and heroin addiction swept across the United States. Meanwhile drug overdose deaths, mostly from opioids, increased from 4,000 in 1999 to over 14,000 in 2008.
An orphan drug becomes a blockbuster medication, just in time to meet the demand created by OxyContin and cheap heroin. With a little imagination, I see a plot for a great conspiracy movie.– Jeffrey T. JunigI don’t know if one, several or a thousand people drove the efforts to create Suboxone, enact the legislation and persuade the FDA and DEA to approve the groundbreaking approach to addiction, but in any case the story will someday make interesting reading. An orphan drug becomes a blockbuster medication, just in time to meet the demand created by OxyContin and cheap heroin. With a little imagination, I see a plot for a great conspiracy movie.
The real story is just as interesting. Our world was struck by an oft-fatal, chronic illness that became a major killer of young adults. The disease affected the sons and daughters of rich and poor alike, killing young descendants of our movie stars and politicians. And as the disease killed at a rate greater than motor vehicle accidents, a British company known for floor cleaning products developed a medication that placed the disease in remission.
The medication had few side effects, and like most medications, had to be taken indefinitely to prevent illness and death. But the life-saving medication could only be prescribed by a fraction of the country’s doctors, and each of those doctors could treat only 100 patients. Those who treated the illness anticipated that the shortage of doctors would create a black market for the drug, but regulators were surprised when people afflicted by the disease scrambled for the medication. Government agencies reacted with rules that made the drug even harder to find.
What happened with buprenorphine? How did the perfect medication for a terrible illness get such a black eye? Is buprenorphine treatment working?
Many doctors who prescribe buprenorphine, including myself, see the medication as the perfect solution for opioid dependence on a planet inhabited by logical people.-Jeffrey T. Junig
Many doctors who prescribe buprenorphine, including myself, see the medication as the perfect solution for opioid dependence on a planet inhabited by logical people. We worry that public sentiment, often driven by misinformation, will result in regulations that create a ‘death spiral’ for buprenorphine. Fewer doctors will be willing to prescribe it, causing a greater proportion of use of non-prescribed buprenorphine. The increased diversion will drive more regulation, pushing more doctors out of the specialty.
Here are a few facts about buprenorphine:
- Suboxone is just one of several forms of buprenorphine.
- Buprenorphine is the active part of Suboxone. Naloxone plays no role in the action. Naloxone was added to prevent IV diversion of buprenorphine, and to change a generic chemical into a marketable medication.
- Buprenorphine is different from other opioids in having a ‘ceiling effect’. The ceiling effect limits the effects of the drug, no matter how much is taken.
- Buprenorphine has been linked to several hundred US deaths over the past ten years—the same number of people who die from acetaminophen in one year. The 400 deaths in ten years related to buprenorphine compare to over 35,000 non-buprenorphine overdose deaths each year.
- It is impossible for most addicts to get ‘high’ from buprenorphine. Most opioid addicts have a tolerance greater than the maximal effect of buprenorphine, causing precipitated withdrawal if buprenorphine is injected, snorted or taken orally within 24 hours of using heroin, methadone or oxycodone. Buprenorphine is used as a bridge by opioid addicts to limit withdrawal when opioid agonists are not available.
- Effects of heroin and other opioid agonists are blocked by buprenorphine.
- The brain cannot tell the difference between molecules of injected buprenorphine and oral buprenorphine, and both are subject to the ceiling effect. People inject buprenorphine because 25 percent of a dose is absorbed orally, whereas 100 percent is absorbed intravenously. In other words, a person taking ‘street Suboxone’ to avoid withdrawal makes a tablet last over a week by injecting the medication.
- Short-term treatment with buprenorphine, i.e. less than one year, is associated with a greater than 90 percent relapse rate when buprenorphine is discontinued, with or without counseling.
- Buprenorphine has few if any side effects and does not lose effectiveness even if taken for many years.
In spite of the usefulness of buprenorphine for treating the epidemic of opioid dependence, public sentiment is more negative than positive. Much of the negative sentiment stems from a lack of understanding of the proper role for buprenorphine. Buprenorphine is criticized, for example, for failing to cure addiction, something it was never intended to do.
Buprenorphine is compared against imaginary treatments that result in long-term sobriety. Proponents of residential treatment point to studies of recovering physicians with success rates of over 50 percent. But treatments for opioid-addicted physicians include years of monitoring and aftercare, with big consequences in the case of relapse. Even if 50 percent was an acceptable efficacy for a potentially-fatal illness (it isn’t), patients not monitored by courtrooms or licensing agencies do not do as well after non-medicated treatments.
Hopefully, addiction will eventually be treated with the same understanding and compassion as other diseases, as deserving of chronic treatment as elevated cholesterol, hypertension or diabetes. Relapse will be seen as an exacerbation of illness that warrants additional attention, rather than a character flaw that triggers discharge from care. Until then, patients will spend money on ineffective treatments, and many will die.
Pro Talk Preview: Jeffrey T. Junig’s next article will describe the factors that discourage physicians from working with buprenorphine.
The cost of alcohol or drug addiction treatment may appear to be an obstacle, but we are here to help. Insurance may cover all or some of your rehab.
Find out if your insurance covers long-term addiction rehabilitation.Check Online Now